
Judge refuses arrest of ex-police chief in Borsellino probe
Prosecutors in Caltanissetta, Sicily, are investigating Gianni De Gennaro, Italy's national police chief from 2000 to 2007 and later head of its intelligence coordination body, on suspicion of obstructing the inquiry into the 1992 bombing that killed anti-mafia judge Paolo Borsellino. They asked for him to be placed under house arrest; a judge refused, and prosecutors have appealed. He has not been charged and is presumed innocent. This piece explains what prosecutors suspect, what the judge decided, who De Gennaro is, and why a bombing from 34 years ago is still under investigation, with the facts as they stood on 17 November 2026.
What happened this week
On Thursday 12 November the carabinieri's special operations unit, the ROS, carried out six search warrants in the province of Rome on the orders of the Caltanissetta prosecutor's office. The searches covered places used by De Gennaro and by people close to him, and the home of Salvatore Contorno, a former member of Cosa Nostra, the Sicilian mafia, who became one of the state's best-known witnesses in the 1980s (Sky TG24, Open).
On Monday 16 November the newspaper Repubblica reported that De Gennaro had received an "avviso di garanzia", the formal notice that tells a person they are under investigation. The same day ANSA and other agencies reported that prosecutors had asked for house arrest and that the judge for preliminary investigations, known in Italy as the GIP, had rejected the request. Prosecutors have appealed to the review court in Caltanissetta, which has set a hearing; the date has not been published. An interview of De Gennaro by prosecutors is scheduled for 1 December, according to ANSA and Sky TG24.
Being under investigation in Italy is an early stage. It means prosecutors are examining a suspicion; it is not an indictment, and no court has assessed the evidence at trial.
What prosecutors suspect
The offence under investigation is "depistaggio", a crime introduced in 2016 that covers misleading or obstructing a criminal investigation. The details below come from the prosecutors' case as reported by the press. None of it has been tested in court.
- Prosecutors suspect that De Gennaro, with the help of two people close to him (the officer assigned to his protection and a retired police inspector), tried to stop Contorno from making statements to the Caltanissetta prosecutors (ANSA, Sky TG24). According to Open, contacts with Contorno began on 1 April 2025, and on 15 May 2025 Contorno chose not to answer the prosecutors' questions.
- They also suspect that documents, on paper and in digital form, were hidden, moved or destroyed with the help of an official of the DIS, Italy's intelligence coordination department. Some of the material concerned Contorno's arrest in 1989 (Il Fatto Quotidiano, Open). Open reports that part of the papers was later recovered.
- According to Open, prosecutors have also listed two aggravating circumstances: acting to help Cosa Nostra, and concealing other people's responsibility for the disappearance of Borsellino's red diary.
The case rests partly on three years of wiretaps and surveillance by the ROS. Repubblica, as reported by Open, published an intercepted remark in which De Gennaro allegedly said, speaking about documents: "By now I've destroyed everything." Open notes that it is not yet clear which papers were kept, moved or destroyed, or whether any of them matter to a criminal case.
The Caltanissetta chief prosecutor, Salvatore De Luca, wrote of an "apparently unjustified concern" on De Gennaro's part about the investigation and about a separate trial on the misdirection of the Borsellino inquiry (Il Fatto Quotidiano, Open).
What the judge decided
The judge rejected every precautionary measure prosecutors had requested in the case. According to ANSA, the judge found that the alleged obstruction was not connected to the disappearance of Borsellino's diary, which is the core of the wider investigation. In the judge's reading, De Gennaro's concerns related to other matters, in particular Contorno's story. Prosecutors argue that the evidence is enough for house arrest, and the review court will now decide.
Who Gianni De Gennaro is
Born in Reggio Calabria in 1948, De Gennaro joined the police in 1973 and spent much of his career fighting the mafia. In 1984 he worked on the extradition from Brazil of Tommaso Buscetta, the first major Cosa Nostra figure to cooperate with the state. He was later director of the DIA, Italy's anti-mafia investigative directorate, and deputy police chief.
| Years | Role (Sky TG24) |
|---|---|
| 2000 to 2007 | Chief of the State Police |
| 2008 to 2012 | Director of the DIS, the department that coordinates Italy's intelligence agencies |
| 2012 to 2013 | Undersecretary to the Prime Minister's Office, responsible for intelligence |
| 2013 to 2020 | Chairman of Leonardo, Italy's state-controlled defence group |
| 2020 to 2022 | Chairman of Banca Popolare di Bari |
| From 2022 | Chairman of Eurolink, the consortium chosen to build the bridge over the Strait of Messina |
No statement from De Gennaro or his lawyers had been reported by the evening of 17 November.
The bombing and the false trail
Paolo Borsellino was killed on 19 July 1992 by a car bomb outside his mother's home in Via D'Amelio, Palermo. Five officers of his police escort died with him. It was 57 days after the Capaci bombing, which killed his colleague and friend Giovanni Falcone, Falcone's wife and three escort officers.
The first investigations were built largely on the statements of Vincenzo Scarantino, a small-time criminal who claimed to have taken part in the attack. His account was false. It led to the conviction of people who had nothing to do with the bombing, and it was taken apart only after Gaspare Spatuzza, a mafia member who began cooperating with prosecutors in 2008, confessed to stealing the car used in the attack. In 2017 a court in Catania cleared the men wrongly convicted on Scarantino's word.
In its written reasons, filed in 2018, the Caltanissetta Assize Court in the fourth Borsellino trial called the affair "one of the most serious misdirections in Italian judicial history". It said Scarantino had been used by "disloyal servants of the state" and linked the misdirection, for the first time in a ruling, to the disappearance of Borsellino's red diary (AGI). Borsellino's family says he always carried the diary with him. His bag ended up in the office of Arnaldo La Barbera, the head of Palermo's police mobile squad, who led the investigation and died in 2002. The diary has never been found.
Three police officers from La Barbera's team were tried for calumny, the crime of falsely accusing someone, in connection with Scarantino's statements. In September 2026 the Court of Cassation confirmed that the charges were time-barred, which closed that case without a final verdict on their guilt (Open, Il Fatto Quotidiano).
Why Contorno and 1989 matter
Contorno was arrested on 26 May 1989 at San Nicola l'Arena, near Palermo, after returning from the United States. The arrest was carried out by La Barbera's mobile squad, while the police's central anti-crime unit, then led by De Gennaro, handled Contorno as a witness (Open, Sky TG24). For prosecutors, the circumstances of that arrest have never been fully explained.
According to Open, investigators are also re-examining other events of 1989, including the anonymous letters sent by the so-called "Corvo di Palermo" ("the Raven of Palermo") against Falcone, and the failed bomb attack on Falcone at his seaside house at Addaura that June. The wider aim of the inquiry, as Sky TG24 puts it, is to establish whether anyone above La Barbera in the state's structures was responsible for the misdirection and for the loss of the diary. These are lines of investigation, not findings.
Reactions
Fiammetta Borsellino, the judge's youngest daughter, told Corriere della Sera that those who led the investigations after the bombings, and those who stayed silent, were each "worried about defending their own personal position" (as reported by Open). She named De Gennaro among several senior figures of the time. The Giornale di Sicilia reported divisions within Parliament's Anti-Mafia Commission over the case; we could not read the details.
What comes next
- The review court's decision on the prosecutors' appeal for house arrest.
- De Gennaro's interview with prosecutors, scheduled for 1 December.
- Any statement from De Gennaro or his lawyers.
- Whether prosecutors ask for a trial. That decision, and a judge's ruling on it, would come later.
ANSA, 16 November 2026; Sky TG24, 16 November 2026 (news report and profile of De Gennaro); Il Fatto Quotidiano, 12 and 16 November 2026, and 16 September 2026; Open, 16 and 17 November 2026, and 16 September 2026; Repubblica (as reported by Open and Il Fatto Quotidiano); Corriere della Sera (as reported by Open, 17 November 2026); AGI, 1 July 2018 (reasons of the Borsellino quater ruling); Giornale di Sicilia, 17 November 2026 (headline only).
More in Crime & Justice
See the post on InstagramFound this useful? The Italy Desk is free to read. A small tip helps us keep it that way.
Support us on Ko-fi


